Home Guide to Investing Tiger Brokers Review – Compared vs Interactive Brokers, moomoo and Saxo! How...

Tiger Brokers Review – Compared vs Interactive Brokers, moomoo and Saxo! How competitive are Tiger Brokers fees? (2021 Singapore – Referral Code)

10

 

After our recent review on Moomoo, quite a few readers have asked that we do a review for Tiger Brokers as well.

Both have very similar user interfaces, fees, and free Apple Stock when you sign up.

How competitive is Tiger Brokers vs Moomoo, Interactive Brokers, Saxo and FSMOne today?

What is Tiger Brokers?

Tiger Brokers is listed in the NASDAQ under UP Fintech Holding.

It’s market cap is $2.6 billion, significantly lower than Moomoo (Futu) with a $14.7 billion market cap.

Tiger Brokers is backed by some very strong investors though, including Interactive Brokers, Xiaomi, ZhenFund, and investor Jim Rogers. 

Tiger Brokers Referral Code / Sign Up Bonus (worth $250)

If you’re new to Tiger Brokers, you can get 60 commission free trades, and 1 free Apple share (worth $200) if you sign up and fund $2000.

It’s a very good deal frankly.

Referral link below, but I would strongly suggest reading the entire review first before deciding if Tiger Brokers is appropriate for you (or if you want to go with Interactive Brokers, Moomoo or Saxo): Tiger Brokers Referral Code / Sign Up Bonus

Tiger Brokers Fees – US, Hong Kong and Singapore markets

Let’s start with the Fees.

The full Fees schedule is set out below.

The thing to note about Tiger Brokers is that there are 2 levels of fees (just like Moomoo):

  1. Commission Fee (to buy the stock)
  2. Platform Fee (to use Tiger Brokers)

Let’s say you buy an Apple stock in the US.

You need to pay Commission Fee of minimum $0.99, and Platform Fee of minimum $1.

In total, you pay about $2+ USD to buy the share.

You do get 60 commission free trades when you sign up now, which is a lot of free trades.

Tiger Brokers Forex Fees

Forex Fees are about 0.3% give or take, which is in line with Moomoo and Saxo.

It’s ok, but won’t be comparable to the market leader which is Interactive Brokers.

At Interactive Brokers you get the interbank spot rates + a $2 fee.

Example – Fees for Tiger Brokers vs Moomoo vs Interactive Brokers

To give an example, here are the fees if you trade on Hong Kong (Tencent), Singapore (DBS), and US (Apple) below.

Long story short – they are all very competitive against each other.

Both Tiger Brokers and Moomoo are very competitive for Hong Kong and Singapore, while Interactive Brokers is very competitive for US stocks.

How does Tiger Brokers compare against Saxo, Moomoo, Interactive Brokers and FSMOne?

I’ve compared the fee schedule against the other big brokers – Moomoo, Interactive Brokers, Tiger Brokers and FSM One above.

To sum it up:

  • Tiger Broker’s fees are very close to Moomoo
  • Tiger Brokers is cheaper than FSMOne
  • Tiger Brokers is cheaper than interactive brokers in some areas (HK and China), but more expensive in other areas (US and Europe)

Tiger Brokers Fees vs Moomoo Fees

You can take a closer look at Moomoo’s fees below.

Tiger Brokers has almost identical fees – which is clearly not a coincidence.

It’s funny because before Moomoo came into the market, Tiger Brokers had higher fees.

After Moomoo came in, Tiger Brokers adjusted their fees downward to match Moomoo. And they also added the referral code for a free Apple stock – Exactly like Moomoo.

Who said competition isn’t great for the consumer?

Tiger Brokers vs Saxo vs Moomoo vs Interactive Brokers vs FSMOne?

But long story short – every single broker on the list above is very competitive in terms of fees.

And if you want dirt cheap fees, Tiger Brokers, Moomoo, Saxo and Interactive Brokers are about as cheap as it gets. Almost all are running referral promotions now with a sign up bonus and free trades during the promotion period.

The days of paying your broker $25 plus $2 a month to buy US shares are over. As long as you’re on one of the brokers above, the fees you’re paying is very competitive.

If you’re still on a broker like DBS Vickers or POEMS for your US/HK stocks, it’s probably time to switch.

$25 commission per trade in 2021 is just daylight robbery.

Tiger Brokers – Custodian Structure and not CDP for SGX stocks

If you’re buying Singapore shares on the SGX – It’s important to note that Tiger Brokers uses a Custodian Structure instead of CDP.

This is the same for all the other cheap broker on the list above – Interactive Brokers, Saxo, Moomoo etc. It’s how they achieve the low fees for SGX stocks

So the shares are legally held with Tiger Brokers, and not in your name.

Whether you prefer CDP or Custodian is really a personal call.

Personally for me I like to hold my long term positions in CDP, because it makes receiving annual reports, rights issues, preferential offerings etc much easier. When you hold shares in custodian these things can be tricky, and it’s hard to attend an AGM/EGM because your name is not on the official list of shareholders.

But frankly, if you’re just holding trading positions, and don’t expect to hold them more than a few months, I would say go for a custodian structure and enjoy the cheaper fees (Tiger Brokers, Moomoo, Interactive Brokers etc).

If you want CDP access, DBS Vickers Cash Upfront is one of the cheapest at $10 per trade (only works for buy orders – $25 to sell). If you really want to save fees you can use FSMOne to sell via CDP for the $10 sell orders. You do need to fill in the paperwork to link FSMOne to your CDP account though.

Margin Rates for Tiger Brokers (vs Interactive Brokers vs Moomoo)

Margin rates for Tiger Brokers are really high – not competitive in this market.

It’s the same story for Moomoo (Futu)

 If you want to use margin go with Interactive Brokers which has very, very competitive margin rates.

Options Trading on Tiger Brokers

Tiger Brokers has tools for basic options trading as well, just like Moomoo.

It’s sufficient if all you need to do is buy a bunch of deep out of the money call options on Gamestop.

But if you want to do serious options trading, or execute more sophisticated strategies, it’s probably not going to be enough.

If you want a more sophisticated options trading platform, I would suggest sticking with Interactive Brokers.

How Safe / Reliable is Tiger Brokers? MAS Licensed? SIPC Insured?

I’ve had a couple of questions about the reliability of brokers like Tiger Brokers, given that it is China backed broker.

Just like Moomoo – What I would say is that Tiger Brokers is Nasdaq listed, and they are also MAS licensed. This does reduce the risk of something going bad.

U.S. securities in your account are also protected up to $500,000 by Securities Investor Protection Corporation (SIPC).

But frankly, there is no stock broker in this world that is zero risk.

In today’s world, there’s always an element of counterparty risk, unless the shares are legally held in your name.

Even with Interactive Brokers I wouldn’t say the risk is zero.

If you’re concerned, I would say use a few brokers, and spread your money around. No need to put your entire life savings into any 1 broker. It’s what I do as well.

Should you transfer your existing shares into Tiger Brokers?

Another frequent question I get is whether it’s worth it to transfer your existing shares into Tiger Brokers.

Maybe you already have a bunch of Google shares in POEMs. But you’re sick of paying the $2 a month custody fee.

Does it make sense to pay to transfer your existing shares into Tiger Brokers?

My personal view is that it’s not worth the time and effort.

I personally have my stocks split over 5 or more brokers. I don’t see a compelling need to have all my stocks in one broker, since I track them via an Excel spreadsheet anyway.

In fact there’s even diversification benefits to having multiple brokers – you avoid having all your eggs in one basket.

You never know what technical or regulatory issue will come up in the next market crisis.

But ultimately it’s a personal call – some investors like the convenience and ease of tracking with having all their stocks with one broker.

Personal Experience with Tiger Brokers

In the name of “market research” I have opened stock broking accounts with literally all the brokers out there – Saxo, Interactive Brokers, Tiger Brokers, moomoo (Futu), DBS Vickers, Standard Chartered Online Trading, FSMOne etc.

You name it, and I probably have an account with them.

After playing around with all the online trading platforms, my personal experience is:

  • Tiger Brokers is the closest to Moomoo in terms of User Experience and UI. The main difference is that Tiger Brokers is more gamified, and in my view easier to use / navigate.
  • All the functions are very easy to locate, and it didn’t take long to get up to speed.
  • All in, it’s a very comfortable and functional broker to use.

Contrast that with something like Interactive Brokers where it does take some time to get up to speed, because the functions are less intuitive.

Personal View – Is Tiger Brokers a good online trading platform to use?

The way I see it, all 4 brokers below are very competitive among each other:

  • Tiger Brokers
  • moomoo (Futu)
  • Saxo
  • Interactive Brokers

There are pros and cons for each, but you won’t go too wrong picking from any of the 4 stock brokers.

I personally have accounts with all 4 brokers, and I buy using from all of them, with Saxo and Interactive Brokers as my main accounts.

What if you’re starting fresh today – Which Stock Broker to pick?

If you’re starting fresh today, I would say:

  • Casual Investor – Tiger Brokers or moomoo (Futu)
  • Serious Investor – Interactive Brokers
  • Mix of the two – Saxo

But like I said, all 4 are very competitive, and it ultimate boils down to personal preference.

If you’re on the fence, just open an account with all 4 and play around a bit. With Singpass it literally takes 5 mins to open an account these days.

Play around the user interface, and decide which one works best for you. Some people like the cute gamified version of Tiger, some the more serious version from Interactive Brokers and Saxo, some the functional layout of moomoo.

Figure out what works for you.

Interactive Broker waives their inactivity fee

In case you missed it, Interactive Brokers announced they will be waiving their $10 a month inactivity fee (previously it was $10 a month if your account value was below $100k USD.

With this change, Interactive Brokers becomes very competitive even at smaller amounts, and is definitely worth checking out.

The Interactive Brokers interface is more complex than moomoo or Tiger Brokers though, and it does take some getting used to. There’s also no free Apple stock if you sign up, which is almost $200 worth of value right there.

With Tiger Brokers, you get 60 free commission trades, and a free Apple stock, collectively worth almost $250. That’s a big plus point in favour of Tiger Brokers.

If you’re still on a DBS Vickers / POEMs and paying $25 per trade + $2 a month for US share, it’s really time for a new broker.

Tiger Brokers Referral Code / Sign up Bonus (worth $200)

Registration:

  1. 500 Tiger Coins (loyalty points that you can redeem for gifts)

Account Opening

  1. 60 Commission-Free Trades (within 180 Days)
  2. 5 Commission-Free Trades for Futures (within 30 Days)

First Deposit SGD 2,000        

  1. 1 FREE Apple share (worth $200)
  2. Stock Voucher of SGD5

Tiger Brokers Referral Code / Sign Up Bonus

moomoo Singapore Referral Code:

Get 1 free Apple share (worth $200) you’re new to MooMoo and fund $2700.

Moomoo Referral Code / Sign Up Bonus

Saxo Singapore Referral Code / Promotion

If you fund $3000 and make 1 stock trade, you also get $100.

Link is below, drop me an email at saxo@financialhorse.com for the next steps!

Referral Link: Financial Horse x Saxo Affiliate Link

Interactive Brokers Referral Code / Promotion

Interactive Brokers Referral Code

Join Financial Horse’s Investing Community!

10 COMMENTS

  1. For trading Singapore stocks, using your DBS example, if you buy $5000 DBS shares instead of $3100, Moo Moo may be cheaper than Tiger Brokers using its commission + platform fee structure. In general, Tiger Brokers is cheaper than Moo Moo if you purchase less than $3150 for that share on the same day.
    By having minimum commission of $0.99 and minimum platform fee of $1.50 and no amalgamation of orders, Moo Moo makes its clients pay actual commission rate that can be really high if the market works against them. Imagine someone in the market sell you 100 Company xx shares at $0.10 and you cannot amalgamate your orders to lower down your actual commission rate.
    FSMOne (IFAST) is actually cheaper if you buy in bulk as it charges flat rate of $8.80 and you can amalgamate your orders on the same day.

  2. Interactive Brokers lowered their commissions for HK stocks to 5 bps if you use the sliding scale. So less expensive across the board.

  3. Tq for the great article,… I am delighted with the following sentence in your article above : At Interactive Brokers you get the interbank spot rates + a $2 fee.
    Is the above good rate only for converting between SGD-to-USD and for USD-to-SGD; or this good rate is also applicable for other currency pairs, eg SGD-to-AUD ?

    Would just like to make a comparison here : what is the current rate in IBKR now for SGDUSD, USDSGD and for SGDAUD ?

    • Yeah good question. I just checked:

      SGD/USD – 0.734
      USD/SGD – 1.3624
      SGD/AUD – 1.0284

      Basically, very close to spot for USD pair, slightly less so for AUD pair.

      • Tq bro,… that was very helpful,….

        How much does it cost to TT USD into Tiger Brokers and into Moomoo ? How long does it take for the funds to be available for use after sending out from, say, our DBS Multi-Currency Acct using DBS Remit ?

  4. Costs, fees and freebies aside, I think you are missing a main point.

    For me, Tiger broker is not for serious options traders. I have been using Tiger broker since Feb 2021 and was comfortable using it as you mentioned. However, as I learnt more about trading, I realized Tiger does not provide me with enough “weapons” to fight the battle.

    1) Not able to make concurrent trade orders such as “Stop Loss Order” and “Sell Order” for the same trade. I make at least 100 trades a month and sometimes have as many as 10 open positions. How can I possibly monitor the price of every single one of them and manually do a buy or sell?

    2) Being in Asia and trading US options, there is a huge time difference and I will not be able to monitor the market overnight. Each time, I have to choose to either defend (Stop loss) or attack (Limit order). I have no choice but to defend right? But so many times, the market went up, hit my target profit level and came down, taking out my stop loss order.

    3) No “Trailing stop loss order” to choose from. This is a very useful “weapon” and allows you to ride the up or down trend until it reverses. I am not sure how everyone else is trading with Tiger, but if you are a serious day trader, you certainly need this “weapon”.

    4) I have changed to Moomoo and now I have 8 “weapons” to choose. “Limit, Market, Stop Limit, Stop, Limit if Touched, Market if Touched, Trailing Stop Limit and Trailing Stop”. Best of all, I can also make concurrent orders for the same trade!

    5) This is really really important because by setting all your stop loss and target margin, you completely remove your emotions and just let the bot execute your plan. You only have to focus on finding the right setup for entry. How many times have the market come down and you find yourself hesitating to cut the loss, hoping it will rebound and then market just goes down further and further until you bleed till you have no blood left?

    6) Lastly, the only freebie I got from Tiger was when I made >100 trades a month to qualify as a “Gold trader” and I got 1 x free UBS share worth around US$17 from Tiger. For Moomoo, I deposited SGD$2.7K and I got 1 x free Pfizer share worth around US$47. After I made 3 trades, I got another 1 x free Pfizer. (All vaccines come in 2 shots right?)

    My conclusion: IF you find yourself losing more than winning with Tiger, you have to wonder is it your problem or you don’t have enough “weapons” at your disposal? I have already feedback before to Tiger but so far nothing changed. If you don’t believe me, try it yourself and good luck!

    • Yes I agree, thanks for raising this point. I don’t think Tiger is designed for traders or more advanced investors.

      Actually for serious traders, IBKR is a good option worth looking at.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here