Luna UST plunges 99% – What is going on? Should you buy Luna?

13

 

In a week that was action packed with events, the standout event will have to be the death of Luna / UST.

This is one for the ages… that we’ll still be talking about years from now.

It has broader implications, so it’s important to understand what happened.

  

What happened to Terra (Luna) / Terra USD (UST)?

Here’s the 5 day chart of Terra (Luna).

It’s nothing short of complete destruction.

What was formerly the 4th largest cryptocurrency just 1 month ago, has now plunged 99.9%:

Here’s the stablecoin TerraUSD (UST).

Remember that the people holding UST believed that they were holding something as good as USD.

Which now very clearly isn’t – down 82% as we speak:

To really understand this and why it matters, we need to start at the top.

What is a Stablecoin?

If you want to transfer USD to anyone today, you need to use the banking system.

Just ask Russia, North Korea, or Iran.

Even for the more law abiding out there, the USD banking system comes with its own set of intricacies and quirks. Not to mention hefty fees.

To get around all this hassle, the crypto community came up with the concept of a stablecoin.

Basically, it is the crypto version of USD.

1 Stablecoin = 1 USD, and you can transfer it freely using crypto networks, without all the hassle that comes with the banking system.

Types of Stablecoin

But how do you actually create a stablecoin?

There are 3 ways:

  1. Fiat Pegged Stablecoin
  2. Crypto Backed Stablecoin
  3. Algorithmic Stablecoin

Fiat Pegged Stablecoin

The simplest form of Stablecoin.

Tether (USDT) is the best example.

Each Tether is backed by 1 USD.

So if there is 1 million Tether out there, it means there is 1 million USD in a bank somewhere that backs up every single Tether in circulation.

Of course, there are many people who dispute this (that Tether is fully backed), but that’s a story for another day.

The advantage with Fiat Pegged Stablecoins is that they are very simple and straightforward.

The drawback is that you need to store the USD somewhere, and banks are not very fond of helping the crypto community.

And it also limits growth, because you cannot issue more Stablecoins without first getting more USD.

Crypto Backed Stablecoin

The logical improvement, is the crypto backed stablecoin.

Instead of backing it with fiat currency, you back it with cryptocurrency.

Say Bitcoin, or Ethereum.

And because cryptocurrency prices are very volatile, you need to overcollateralise it.

So for every 1 USD stablecoin, you may hold 1.5 USD worth of Bitcoin/Ethereum.

The best example of this is DAI (Maker Dao).

The problem with Crypto Backed Stablecoins are pretty similar to fiat backed stable coins.

You solve the problem of having to store USD, but you still have the problem on growth.

Because you need to overcollateralise, it limits growth.

Algorithmic Stablecoin

If you think that the above tracks the evolution of fiat currency (paper money), you are exactly right.

The next logical evolution then, is obvious to everyone.

Just as Nixon unpegged the USD from Gold in 1971, a few guys in the Crypto world figured why not do the same for Stablecoins.

Enter the Algorithmic Stablecoins.

These are not backed by any USD or cryptocurrency.

They are essentially backed by confidence.

And of course, Luna (Terra) grew to become the largest algorithmic stablecoin.

What is LUNA (Terra)?

There are 2 coins that you need to know:

  1. TerraUSD – the Stablecoin
  2. Terra (LUNA) – the token

The core premise, and this is crucial because it underpins everything that is to come, is that:

1 UST can always be redeemed for 1 USD worth of LUNA

And vice versa – 1 USD worth of LUNA can always be redeemed for 1 UST

Some Examples…

It’s easier to understand with a few examples.

Let’s say UST trades at $0.80

A savvy investor will buy 1 UST (at $0.80), redeem it for 1 USD of LUNA, and sell the LUNA for a $0.20 profit

More Examples…

Let’s say instead UST trades at $1.10

The savvy investor will now buy 1 USD of Luna, swap it for 1 UST (worth $1.10), and sell the UST for a $0.10 profit.

All good so far?

Where is the incentive to hold UST?

Now to really drive demand for UST, you need an incentive right?

Enter the Anchor Protocol.

Basically – you earn 19.5% interest p.a. to stake (hold) UST.

That’s a pretty attractive interest rate, which drove a lot of demand for UST. There are reports of people converting their life savings into UST, and living off the 19.5% interest.

But of course, when something is too good to be true, it almost always is.

And if you’re asking where is the money coming from to pay the 20% interest?

Well, that’s exactly where the problem begins.

Structure works well on the way up (Luna price high)

The thing about this entire structure, is that it works very well on the way up, when Luna prices are soaring.

Let’s say Luna’s price is $1 million.

This means that every 1 Luna token can be swapped for 1 million UST.

That means a small bit of Luna is burned to mint a lot of UST.

UST supply is high relative to Luna supply, and the entire system purrs along.

Price of Luna keeps going up, and everyone is happy.

This was Luna for the past year.

Structure is unstable on the way down (Luna price fall)

On the way down though, everything reverses.

Let’s say Luna’s price falls to $0.5.

This means that I can take my 1 million UST, and convert into 2 million Luna.

The supply of Luna goes up exponentially, pressuring Luna prices on the way down.

Which means that Luna’s structure is inherently pro-cyclical.

It amplifies the move up, but it also amplifies any crash.

Enter… the Luna Central Bank

If it isn’t obvious to you by now, Luna is a confidence backed currency, no difference from the USD or paper money.

And with all confidence backed currencies, your biggest fear is a run on the bank.

The solution, which the US discovered 100 years ago – is to create a central bank.

Luna stumbled on the exact same solution.

Luna’s “Central Bank”, is the Luna Foundation Guard (LFG).

Why does Luna pay you 19.5% p.a. to hold UST?

Remember that Anchor Protocol pays you 19.5% p.a. to hold UST.

Why do they want to do this?

Very simply, the reason is that as more people hold UST:

  1. LUNA is burned for UST
  2. UST is staked (taken out of circulation)
  3. LUNA price goes up
  4. LUNA’s Central Bank (which holds a lot of LUNA reserves) sells LUNA to raise dollars.

And the hope is that:

  1. UST takes off as a widely used stablecoin before LFG runs out of money paying the 19.5% p.a.
  2. Luna price goes to the moon

Or to put it very simply, Luna pays you 19.5% to hold UST, so that Luna’s price will go up, so they can sell more Luna to raise money to pay you the 19.5%.

So FH… you’re telling me that Luna is a ponzi scheme?

I know this sounds exactly like a ponzi scheme, but to be really fair to them, so is the fractional banking system and the USD.

The only difference is that the USD has the US Government / Federal Reserve, and Luna only has LFG.

But if you go back into the early 1900s before the Federal Reserve was formed, you’ll find that the USD faced the exact same problems.

So these problems are not unique to crypto, they are a standard feature of currencies.

This is important to understand.

With the USD you have the US military and government to enforce restrictions if s*** hits the fan. Crypto for now… doesn’t.

Hence when things blow up, they blow up spectacularly.

BTW – we share commentary on Singapore Investments every week, so do join our Telegram Channel (or Telegram Group), Facebook and Instagram to stay up to date!

Don’t forget to sign up for our free weekly newsletter too!

Just created a Discord server where I collate analyst reports and investing resources that I come across in my research. Hit us up here if you’re keen.

 

The Death Spiral

In any case, what happens next is fairly obvious to anyone who follows money generally.

The broad steps are:

  1. UST is dumped
  2. UST depegs from $1 due to selling pressure
  3. As the peg is pressured, more UST holders start to panic and redeem their UST for $1 of LUNA to sell
  4. The newly minted LUNA gets dumped, sending LUNA prices lower
  5. Existing UST holders start to worry, so they redeem for LUNA to sell
  6. Repeat until you have a run on LUNA

LFG will defend the peg

Of course, at this point the Luna central bank, LFG, starts propping up LUNA by selling its Bitcoin reserves.

Breaking the Bank of England… Crypto Style

But just as the Bank of England discovered 30 years ago, once the panic starts, it takes on a life of its own.

LFG eventually runs out of reserves and gives up defending the peg.

UST prices collapse:

As do Luna prices.

UST holders rush to convert their UST into Luna, which are then sold immediately.

This increases the supply of Luna exponentially, sparking hyperinflation in Luna.

Latest Updates on Luna

At some point in time, the Terra blockchain is halted entirely.

And Luna trading is halted on many crypto exchanges.

This is the death of Luna

There’s no sugarcoating this one.

Luna is in the hyperinflation phase of the Weimar Republic or Zimbawe.

When any currency enters this phase, there almost never is any way back.

The only realistic solution is to abandon the currency entirely, and replace it with a new currency that is backed by collateral.

In the past that would be gold or the USD, in crypto terms that might be Bitcoin or Ethereum.

Of course, it’s also possible that a white knight can come in with a massive cash infusion to save the entire project, but frankly it’s hard to see why anyone would want to do that.

This is probably the end of Luna in its current form.

I was lucky… sold my LUNA at $100 months back… but others are less lucky

Full disclosure that I hold no positions in Luna.

I was lucky to have exited my Luna positions completely at $100 a few months back.

And I say this without any trace of schadenfreude, because I know how painful it is to be burned by markets.

My heart goes out to all those who are affected.

Hearing some talk about suicide, and I really want to say, whatever it is – money is just money.

Nothing is worth taking your life over.

Move on, and build back stronger. Live to fight another day.

You can always make it all back again.

This is not the end.

Personal Views on Crypto

I’ve been saying this for a while, and I still think Crypto is in the early 2000s phase of the internet.

Lots of hype, lots of promise, and lots of crazy valuations.

Just like the Dot Com crash wiped out a whole generation of startups, the coming Fed Hiking cycle will do the same to many Crypto projects.

But those that remain, will be defined by this time, and will emerge stronger.

And over the next 10 – 20  years, perhaps we can start to see the FAANG equivalent emerge in the Crypto space. And which will change the world.

From a pure investment perspective, most of my holdings are in the “Blue Chips” of Bitcoin and Ethereum.

I still think they hold the best potential, at least for now.

Sure, the altcoins can be used to flip in and out to make a quick buck, but I wouldn’t hold them long term, at least not in this macro climate.

As always – love to hear what you think!

 

As always, this article is written on 14 May 2022 and will not be updated going forward. Latest thoughts (and my stock watch and personal portfolio) are available on Patreon.

 

Looking to buy Bitcoin, Ethereum, or Crypto?

Check out our guide to the best Crypto Exchange here.

Looking for a low cost broker to buy US, China or Singapore stocks?

Get 1 free Apple share (worth $230) you’re new to MooMoo and fund $2700.

Get a Free Apple stock (worth S$230) when you open a new account with Tiger Brokers and fund $2000.

Special account opening bonus for Saxo Brokers too (drop email to [email protected] for full steps).

Or Interactive Brokers for competitive FX and commissions.

 

Do like and follow our Facebook and Instagram, or join the Telegram Channel. Never miss another post from Financial Horse!

Looking for a comprehensive guide to investing that covers stocks, REITs, bonds, CPF and asset allocation? Check out the FH Complete Guide to Investing.

Or if you’re a more advanced investor, check out the REITs Investing Masterclass, which goes in-depth into REITs investing – everything from how much REITs to own, which economic conditions to buy REITs, how to pick REITs etc.

Want to learn everything there is to know about stocks? Check out our Stocks Masterclass – learn how to pick growth and dividend stocks, how to position size, when to buy stocks, how to use options to supercharge returns, and more!

All are THE best quality investment courses available to Singapore investors out there!

 

FYI – We just launched the FH Property Series. Everything you need to know to buy a property in Singapore, completely free of charge.

 

13 COMMENTS

  1. Nice write up, FH!

    Anything can be money as long as stakeholders agree it is. In the past, Cowrie shells have served this purpose as has large boulders as can be seen at the Singapore Mint. So crypto like Bitcoin can be the next gold or the next cowrie shell, I don’t know which.

    Nonetheless, there is a fundamental difference between fiat money issued by governments and pseudo money issued by companies. The former can collect revenues through taxes to pay debt. But if printing is excessive and debt is too high, then even government fiat becomes like a Ponzi which the USD risks becoming like you said.

    Having a system with monopoly money backed by Game of Life money and pretending it was real money like Luna/UST was only ever going to work by relying on the greed of people for extraordinarily high 20% returns paid for by new participants, the classic Ponzi scheme. Every generation creates a new version for that generation to fall for. This is simply the latest iteration and now people have seen that the emperor has no clothes.

    • Well at least one good that crypto has brought is that it’s forced all of us to question the value of money itself. Why does USD have value over Bitcoin? Is it because people perceive it to have value? Is it because of the backing of the US military?

      Like you have mentioned, these questions are as old as money itself. And we’re at a very interesting phase in the long term debt cycle, where in the years ahead, the very same questions may be asked of the USD itself.

      • What maintains the USD is its status as THE reserve and trade currency. If that ever falls away, the USD will collapse like a house of cards under the weight of unsustainable debt. One day in a perhaps medium or distant future, historians may point to the US monetary sanctions on Russia’s Central bank as the biggest mistake causing the decline of the US. Every central banker around the world is going to want to find a way to diversify away from the USD.

        Bitcoin is the nearer term question. Will it be the next gold or the next Luna? I don’t know which way it will end up.

  2. 1. I have printed a new Monopoly money, today I say it is worth US$1. Come and buy!
    “Don’t kid lah…liddat also can meh.”

    2. It is true. I have backed it up with another new Game of Life money which I have also just started printing. You can exchange my Monopoly money for my Game of Life money. If my Monopoly money falls, you can just exchange it for my Game of Life money and pocket the difference. See, I have written a fancy paper about how it works, don’t worry, it is all backed up by sophisticated algorithms that I have developed.
    “Eh, still skeptical lah. What is all this, I don’t really understand what you are saying.”

    3. Tell you what, you try and I will pay you 20% interest on the Monopoly money you buy and deposit in my virtual bank. I print both the types of money backing each other up and I also run the virtual bank holding this money. It is very safe.
    “20%, that’s quite a lot. Maybe I just try a little bit.”

    4. See, it is working, you are getting your 20%. Why don’t you also share this with your friends, we can all mint money together.
    “Yah, you are right, I am really getting my interest.”

    5. Now you have become rich right, I told you this is legitimate. The whole world knows about us now, we are very safe.
    “Yes, I have become super rich in a short time thanks to you. Now I will put in all my savings and also tell all my friends and relatives about the Golden goose I have found. Before you know it, I will be able to buy a GCB, no sweat!” 20% a year on my Monopoly money and your Game of Life money is also shooting through the roof!

    6. Wonderful, just wonderful! We are all in this together and we will all get rich together.
    “Eh, I hear some people are questioning your money and the price is coming down.”

    7. Don’t worry, you see, I have also purchased other people’s Monopoly money to back up my Monopoly money.
    “Eh, now the price is really falling like a rock. Worse, my 6 year old told me this story about the Emperor actually not having any clothes whereas the whole world was saying the Emperor was wearing such fine, delicate clothes.”

    8. Uh oh, looks like you have just taken the red pill like in the Matrix.
    “X$#%%#[email protected], I have lost all my money now. Turns out, this is all fake money, I must have been a LUNATIC for believing you!”

    9. Actually, that is what I have called you from Day 1. You cannot blame me if you did not take the hint. It has been a tiring few days, I need to take a rest in my GCB, sorry you couldn’t buy one but thanks for helping me buy mine.

    • 10. By the way, don’t bother making a police report like one blogger has done. In the old days, maybe they would have investigated this as a Ponzi scheme but today, what I do is called Financial Innovation and Fintech. You remember that no banker got sent to jail for causing the 2008 Financial crisis, right?

  3. To me crypto currency is scam at the ultimate level created by the smartest brain of this ear…look, you can create unlimited variants of crypto coins and claim each version is more superior than the other….at the end of the day….they are just number crunching using better CPU…..unlike gold or silver which is finite….as the old saying silence is “golden”……That was the testimonial…..the mineral is desirable since ancient time….I have not heard of silence is “crypto”…I have not seen someone burried with “crypto” or someone wearing an “crypto”, you can’t build thing with crypto and you can’t eat crypto but you definately can with gold 🙂

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here